AI legal assistants compared

What Is an AI Legal Assistant, and Which One Fits a Small Firm?

Updated November 16, 2026

Short answer: An AI legal assistant is software that drafts, summarizes, reviews and researches for a lawyer, who stays responsible for every word it produces. The products sold under that name differ mainly in their source material (a publisher's law library or your own documents) and in what they store, so a small firm should pick by those two things rather than by the label.

It does first drafts and first passes. Thomson Reuters titles its CoCounsel Legal page "AI Legal Assistant" and says it "handles research, analysis, and drafting" from a single query (CoCounsel Legal). LexisNexis describes Lexis+ with Protégé as "a legal AI solution for research, analysis, and drafting" built around its Protégé AI assistant (LexisNexis). Spellbook sells an agent called Associate, "The first AI agent that can work through multi-document legal matters, with your oversight" (Spellbook).

What none of them does is take responsibility. Thomson Reuters puts it plainly on its own FAQ: "Professionals remain responsible for the advice they give, the decisions they make, and the work they sign off on" (Thomson Reuters).

Is an AI paralegal the same as a human paralegal under the ethics rules?

No, but the supervision duty looks similar. ABA Formal Opinion 512 applies the supervision rules to AI: "Managerial lawyers must establish clear policies regarding the law firm's permissible use of GAI, and supervisory lawyers must make reasonable efforts to ensure that the firm's lawyers and nonlawyers comply with their professional obligations when using GAI tools" (p. 10). In practice, treat an AI assistant's draft the way you would a new hire's: useful, fast and checked before it goes anywhere (ABA Formal Opinion 512).

The choices fall into three groups: publisher platforms (CoCounsel Legal, Lexis+ with Protégé), legal AI platforms (Harvey, Spellbook) and general AI tools (ChatGPT Business, Claude Team, Faradex).

Listed alphabetically, with no ratings. Each line is from the vendor's own page, read on November 16, 2026.

Tool Source material How you buy it What it says about your data
ChatGPT Business (OpenAI) General model, plus files you upload Self-serve, for teams of 2 to 200 employees "No training on your business data by default"; chats kept until deleted or removed by your admin's retention setting
Claude Team (Anthropic) General model, plus files you upload Self-serve, "For teams of 2 to 150" "No model training on your content by default"; Anthropic says "we retain your chats and coding sessions in the product"
CoCounsel Legal (Thomson Reuters) "authoritative Westlaw content" and Practical Law guidance "Contact us about plans for law firms" Content and prompts deleted "in accordance with the customer's retention policy"; backups hosted "in separate availability time zones in the U.S."
Faradex Your own files, in your firm's Workspace From $120 a month for one person; team sizes on faradex.ai/pricing Files and conversations are held in memory and are gone when the Workspace is reset
Harvey Your documents and legal sources; Ask LexisNexis is a separate add-on Demo, then a quote; "several hundred dollars per user per month" on average "Harvey doesn't use inputs, outputs or uploaded documents to train underlying models"; you "set retention policies"
Lexis+ with Protégé (LexisNexis) LexisNexis content "Request a trial" "We never use customer data to train AI models"
Spellbook Your contracts, inside Microsoft Word "Start your 7-day free trial" or "Book a Demo" Zero data retention with "both OpenAI and Anthropic"; "Other third party services are used that may store or process customer information"

Claude's storage quote is from Anthropic's privacy center. ChatGPT Business, Claude Team and Faradex are general AI tools, not legal research databases.

How should a small firm choose one?

Start from the work, not the brand:

  • If most of your AI use would be legal research, the publisher platforms answer from a library you can cite, which a general tool cannot.
  • If most of it is drafting and reviewing your own documents, a general plan, a Word add-in or a private workspace may do the job at a lower, published price.
  • If the documents are highly sensitive, weigh what each tool stores above its features. A vault you can return to next month is also a store of client files someone else holds.

Then run one real task through your top two choices and compare the time saved after your own review.

File, send or advise. Opinion 512 warns that "output from a GAI tool must be carefully reviewed to ensure that the assertions made to the court are not false" (p. 10), and courts have sanctioned lawyers who skipped that step. Keep a person between the assistant and anything that leaves the firm, and see AI Ethics for Lawyers for the cases.

For the AI tools built specifically around contracts, see AI contract review for small firms. For the wider picture, see AI for law firms.

Prices and terms change. Check each vendor's current page before you buy. This guide is general information, not legal advice.

About Faradex. Faradex is a private AI workspace for small and mid-sized firms that handle confidential client work. Each firm gets its own Workspace on dedicated infrastructure in the United States. Files and conversations are held in memory and are gone when the Workspace is reset. AI model: Currently Opus via AWS Bedrock, more information is available on our website. AWS does not store prompts or responses, and model providers have no access to them. Pricing: from $120 a month, no seat minimum; see faradex.ai/pricing.